Cousin J sent me the following info which was written quite some time ago but is great in its summary of the churches in that area back in the early days. And since I can't seem to keep it straight in my brain, I thought I would post it here, which always helps me remember better!
From: Diane Ward < dsives@ROOTSQUEST.com>
Subject: St James Lutheran Church, Greenwich, Warren County
Date: Tue, 21 Apr 1998 13:14:15 -0400
Since Warren County was a part of Essex
County, and there is no Warren County mailing list yet, I have decided to
provide a few facts here about this church. I am a lookup volunteer for
Warren County as I have the cemetery inscriptions and yesterday, I added
the Baptisms beginning in 1770 - 1836 and a list of communicants from
The article which was in The Genealogical Magazine
of New Jersey in Volumes 8 and 9 talks about the early church.
says that the early records of the church..those from about 1750
to 1769 have been lost. Originally there was a union between the
German Reformed and the Lutheran Churches but the German
Reformed church fizzled out by people moving away and deaths. The
church, early on, was affiliated with St. Michael's Lutheran Church in
Traditions has it that the first church was
constructed of logs and thatched with straw..this is how it became known
as "The Straw Church".
The second church was built in 1790. The
third building was built in 1834.
The first pastors beginning in
the year 1770 were Christian Streit and Peter Muhlenburg.
Peter Muhlenburg, at the time, was the resident clergyman of Zion
Lutheran Church at New Germantown (now Oldwick), Hunterdon county.
This was the same Peter Muhlenburg who became famous as the Revolutionary
General. Christian Streit was also the pastor of a Lutheran church at